Free: 100 natural living tools, no sign-up ยท Try one
๐Ÿฅ• Food & kitchen

Juice Cleanses: Healthy Habit or Fad? The Honest Answer

Skip multi-day juice fasts. Instead, enjoy one small glass of mostly-vegetable juice with a meal, and eat whole fruit and vegetables for the fiber.

โฑ 4 min read๐Ÿ›ก๏ธ Safety note inside๐Ÿ”Ž Evidence checked
Juice Cleanses: Healthy Habit or Fad? The Honest Answer

Juice cleanses are short programs, usually one to seven days, in which you drink only fruit and vegetable juices, and the honest verdict is that they are mostly a fad: they do not remove toxins, and the weight lost returns quickly. In short, fresh juice can be part of a healthy diet, but living on it is not. However, many people feel lighter for a few days and wonder why. Therefore, this guide explains what really happens, the risks, and better ways to enjoy juice.

Quick answer: skip multi-day juice fasts. Instead, enjoy one small glass of mostly-vegetable juice with a meal, and eat whole fruit and vegetables for the fiber.

What juice cleanses promise, and what happens

PromiseWhat actually happens
“Flushes toxins”The liver and kidneys already do this; juice adds nothing special
“Fast weight loss”Mostly water and stored carbohydrate; it returns with normal eating
“Rests the digestive system”The gut does not need rest; it needs fiber
“Boosts energy”Some people feel light; many feel tired, cold and hungry
“Resets cravings”Blood sugar swings can increase cravings

Six facts about juice cleanses

  1. First, juicing removes most of the fiber, which feeds gut microbes and slows sugar absorption.
  2. Next, fruit-heavy juices deliver a lot of sugar quickly.
  3. Then juice-only days supply very little protein, which muscles and the liver need.
  4. After that, the calorie drop explains the short-term weight change.
  5. Furthermore, high-oxalate juices (spinach, beet, chard) in large amounts can stress the kidneys.
  6. Finally, unpasteurized juice can carry bacteria.

The National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health reports no convincing evidence that detox diets remove toxins, and it lists illness from unpasteurized juice and kidney problems from high-oxalate juices among the risks.

Two glasses of green juice, typical of juice cleanses

Why people feel good at first

  • Less alcohol, caffeine, sugar and processed food. As a result, anyone would feel a difference.
  • More fluids and vitamins than usual.
  • A sense of control and a fresh start.
  • Lost water weight, which looks like progress.

Consequently, the benefits come from what you stop, not from the juice itself. You can keep them without fasting.

๐Ÿณ
Free tool ยท 3 quick questionsWhat's Your Kitchen Personality?

Risks of juice cleanses

RiskWho is most affected
Blood sugar swingsPeople with diabetes or prediabetes
Dizziness, headaches, fatigueAlmost everyone by day two or three
Muscle loss with repeated cleansesOlder adults; frequent “cleansers”
Kidney strain from oxalatesPeople with kidney disease or stones
Foodborne illnessPregnant women, older adults, weak immunity
Triggering restrictive eatingAnyone with a history of eating disorders
Medicine interactionsGrapefruit juice; large vitamin K swings with warfarin

Who should avoid juice cleanses

  • Pregnant or breastfeeding women
  • People with diabetes, kidney disease or gout
  • Anyone with a history of eating disorders
  • Teenagers, children and frail older adults
  • People on regular medicines, unless a doctor agrees

A smarter way to enjoy juice, without juice cleanses

  1. First, keep juice to one small glass (about 150 ml) a day.
  2. Next, make it mostly vegetables, with a little fruit for taste.
  3. Then drink it with a meal that contains protein and fiber.
  4. After that, prefer smoothies sometimes, because blending keeps the fiber.
  5. Finally, wash produce well, and drink fresh juice the same day.

Recipe: everyday green juice

Makes 2 small glasses.

  • 1 cucumber
  • 2 celery stalks
  • 1 green apple
  • 1 handful spinach
  • Half a lemon, peeled
  • 1 small piece fresh ginger

First, wash everything thoroughly. Next, juice it all, or blend with a cup of water for a fiber-rich version. Then drink it with breakfast or lunch.

Shelf life: best fresh; up to 24 hours in a closed jar in the fridge. Safety note: rotate your greens, and keep spinach to a handful, because it is high in oxalates.

Juice, smoothies and whole produce compared

FormFiberFullnessBest use
Whole fruit and vegetablesHighHighEvery day, as the base
SmoothieMostly keptMedium to highA quick breakfast or snack
Fresh juiceLowLowA small glass with a meal
Juice-only daysVery lowLowNot recommended

Better “reset” ideas than juice cleanses

  • Three days of home cooking with vegetables at every meal
  • A week without alcohol and sugary drinks
  • An earlier bedtime for seven nights
  • A daily 20-minute walk

Furthermore, see our guides to daily detox habits, liver detox myths and detox teas.

The shortcut vs the source
ShortcutUltra-processed snacks with long labels
The sourceWhole foods with one ingredient each
ShortcutFlavour from a packet
The sourceHerbs, spices, citrus and good salt
ShortcutStore-bought pickles with preservatives
The sourceFerments your grandparents made in a jar
ShortcutEating whatever is quick
The sourceA one-page weekly plan and a stocked pantry

Safety notes

Stop any cleanse, and eat a normal meal, if you feel faint, shaky, confused or unwell. In addition, see a doctor for lasting fatigue, digestive symptoms or unexplained weight change, instead of trying to fix them with fasting.

Keep going

Next, browse the natural kitchen section for simple meals and drinks.

FAQ: juice cleanses

Do juice cleanses detox the body?

No. The liver and kidneys do that continuously.

Will I lose weight?

Briefly, yes. However, most of it is water, and it returns.

Are one-day juice cleanses harmful?

For most healthy adults, one day is unlikely to harm. Still, it brings no special benefit.

Quick check

Which bread label is a real wholegrain?

Is juice healthier than whole fruit?

No. Whole fruit keeps its fiber.

Is cold-pressed juice better?

It may keep slightly more vitamins. Nevertheless, it is still low in fiber, and often unpasteurized.

What should I do instead?

Eat more vegetables, drink water, sleep well, and move.

Safety note

Natural still needs amounts and care. Patch test new skin products, keep oils and herbs away from small children, and ask a doctor or pharmacist first if you are pregnant, breastfeeding, take medicines or have a health condition.

Your next step

Made for this topic

The Natural Kitchen
Start here

The Natural Kitchen

Ten meal formulas instead of a hundred recipes: learn the shape, swap the ingredients, cook from the cupboard.

The Clean Pantry
Ebook + Companion Planner

The Clean Pantry

Swap your pantry to whole foods one shelf a week: use up first, then swap, so nothing goes…

Fermenting at Home
Ebook + Companion Planner

Fermenting at Home

How much salt for sauerkraut? 2% of the cabbage weight โ€” 20 g per kilo. The full method,…

The Natural Kitchen Bundle ยท 6 products

The Natural Kitchen Bundle

Plan once, shop once, cook twice: a whole-food week with a meal planner, a pantry swap list and 40 recipe cards.

  • EbookThe Natural Kitchen
  • EbookThe Clean Pantry
  • EbookFermenting at Home
  • PrintableWhole-Food Meal Planner
  • PrintablePantry Swap List
  • PrintableWhole-Food Recipe Cards
$37$72 separatelySave $35
Digital download ยท All sales final
The Natural KitchenThe Clean PantryFermenting at HomeWhole-Food Meal PlannerPantry Swap List